MLB Mailbag: Cardinals, Mets, Red Sox, Phillies, Mize

This week’s mailbag will get into the Cardinals’ sturdy begin, the Mets’ horrible offense, what a Mets, Red Sox, or Phillies sell-off may appear like, Casey Mize‘s contract 12 months, and extra.

Andrew asks:

I got here into the 12 months with low expectations for the Cardinals, however we nonetheless have an honest report. How lengthy would the Cardinals want to take care of a profitable report earlier than I get any hopes up about making the playoffs?

FanGraphs is rather more optimistic than PECOTA on this crew, so we’ll go along with their 13.5% playoff odds. The Cardinals have performed .552 ball by 17.9% of their season, however FG requires .462 from right here on out. If the Cards as an alternative play .500 ball for his or her remaining 129, they will win 82-83 video games, which could put them firmly within the combine for a wild card spot till the top.

At 4.83 runs scored per recreation, the Cardinals’ offense ranks sixth within the NL. If they really get into the neighborhood of 800 runs, it might be spectacular for any crew, not only one that entered the season with low expectations.

Nine Cardinals gamers have 60+ PA and account for 85% of the crew’s whole:

• Ivan Herrera – 138 wRC+. The Statcast metrics are sturdy, and even when Herrera cannot preserve a 17% stroll fee, his .278 xBA and .471 xSLG counsel that is principally actual. If so, the Cardinals have a lineup cornerstone at DH/catcher by 2029.
• J.J. Wetherholt – 132 wRC+. The highly-regarded rookie is getting on base and exceeding expectations. He’ll stoop in some unspecified time in the future, however with a 70 hit grade and 55 energy, one could make the case for sturdy manufacturing to proceed even when it seems to be totally different (corresponding to the next batting common).
• Alec Burleson – 115 wRC+. He has a monitor report at this stage, so that is affordable.
• Jordan Walker – 153 wRC+. If this holds up, Walker is a prime ten hitter in baseball. Maybe that is optimistic, however the breakout is backed by Statcast.
• Nolan Gorman – 81 wRC+. He hasn’t actually hit since 2023, though he is OK towards rights and appears advantageous at third base this 12 months. If the Astros fall additional, might the Cardinals make a commerce for Isaac Paredes?
• Masyn Winn – 103 wRC+. He’s hitting to expectations.
• Victor Scott II – 39 wRC+. Scott is not in there for his bat, however appears best-suited for a fourth outfielder function.
• Nathan Church – 106 wRC+. The speedy 25-year-old got here into the 12 months as only a 40-grade prospect and might also lack the bat to be a starter, however he hit properly within the higher minors. I’m unsure I’d need Scott and Church in the identical lineup, however they’re a powerful defensive pair. Thomas Saggese is on this combine, and prospect Joshua Baez might be a part of it if he cuts down on strikeouts.
• Peter Pages – 106 wRC+. Pages does have a little bit little bit of pop, however he in all probability cannot hold this up.

Lars Nootbaar He underwent surgical procedure in October to deal with deformities in his heels, and may very well be an excellent June addition able to a 115-120 wRC+. If Nootbaar has a setback, a commerce for the aforementioned Duran or Marsh may very well be fascinating. You can not help however marvel how good this offense would look had the Cardinals retained Contreras and Brendan Donovanalthough.

Bottom line, although: there’s one thing right here with this offense, particularly if Nootbaar can present a lift. And this additionally appears to be among the finest defenses within the NL. What in regards to the pitching facet?

Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription

• Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams, and Anthony Franco.
• Join unique weekly dwell chats with Anthony.
• Remove advertisements and assist our writers.
• Access GM-caliber instruments like our MLB Contract Tracker