How Oneil Cruz Walked Away From Deadly Crash With a Fixer’s Help — ProPublica


Reporting Highlights

  • A Deadly Crash: Six years in the past, Pittsburgh Pirates star prospect Oneil Cruz rear-ended a bike, killing all three of its passengers and jeopardizing his profession.
  • Making It Disappear: Cruz’s mother and father introduced in a fixer to repay the victims’ households so that they wouldn’t sue and wouldn’t demand that prosecutors pursue the case.
  • Behind the Scenes: In making the case go away, that fixer, Santo Caraballo, saved Cruz’s profession and launched his personal as one of the highly effective figures in Dominican baseball.

These highlights have been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.

Around 4 a.m. on Sept. 21, 2020, Luis David Saba arrived at a desolate stretch of freeway alongside the southern coast of the Dominican Republic. Police and paramedics had left by then, taking with them a Jeep Grand Cherokee with a crumpled hood and the tangled stays of a budget bike it had smashed into. Also gone have been the bike’s two critically injured passengers. The solely indicators that an accident had occurred a few hours earlier have been the blood and particles smeared throughout the asphalt and a pile of neatly positioned branches.

Saba knew what to anticipate beneath that pile. It was a Dominican customized to make use of something readily available to shroud a physique deserted by paramedics. Pushing away the branches, Saba noticed shredded garments, torn pores and skin and lengthy, curly hair forming a halo over a battered face. He coated the physique of his 20-year-old youthful brother, Yohan Saba Mercado, with a sheet. In shock, he felt nothing however the necessity to get his brother out of the highway. 

Saba sat and waited for forensic investigators he was instructed have been on their method. Hours handed, the solar rose and site visitors started to stream by them. Finally, he gave up. With the assistance of buddies, he loaded his brother’s physique into a van, and hours later it was at his mom’s home.

“Paper Trail” Podcast

Learn extra about this story on ProPublica’s podcast “Paper Trail.

Later that morning, two different households have been experiencing related horrors. Deby Beato Charles, 20, and Daniela Perez Garcia, 19, had been using on the again of Yohan’s bike when the Jeep rear-ended them. When Deby’s older brother, Ruben, bought to a close by hospital, he was met by a physician who handed him a pockets and bracelet. Deby had died of a extreme head damage and blunt chest trauma. At one other hospital, Daniela’s uncle was ushered into a room the place his niece lay. Her face was so swollen he didn’t acknowledge her. According to her demise certificates, she had suffered accidents to her head, chest and hip and went into hypovolemic shock, through which the lack of bodily fluids causes a individual’s organs to close down. 

The households of Daniela and Yohan held funerals of their houses that afternoon. During the proceedings, phrase unfold about who had been driving the Grand Cherokee. It was Oneil Cruz, a “pelotero,” a ballplayer, with a fortune and a future, the 21-year-old scion of a native baseball household, a high prospect within the Pittsburgh Pirates group. Seemingly everybody within the space knew how a lot he obtained from his main league signing bonus 5 years earlier: $950,000.

The households additionally knew what was going to occur subsequent. 

Yohan’s mom instructed me that after all of the mourners left the home, a driver confirmed up holding out a cellphone. On the road was Cruz’s mom providing condolences — and wanting to barter.


Less than 7 miles from the positioning of the accident is the striving farm city of Nizao. Even although it has a inhabitants of simply 32,000, Nizao has produced dozens {of professional} ballplayers, together with three-time All-Star Ketel Marte and, most famously, Hall of Famer Vladimir Guerrero Sr., among the finest hitters in fashionable baseball and father of Vladimir Jr., the star first baseman for the Toronto Blue Jays. Looming over the principle highway into city is the Guerreros’ mansion. Right beneath it, a large 27 has been carved into the hill — the jersey quantity the 2 share.

A mural of Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. in Nizao

By 2020, Oneil Cruz Ureña seemed poised to be among the many better of Nizao’s ballplayers. The Los Angeles Dodgers signed him when he was 16 and over 6 toes tall. They traded him to the Pittsburgh Pirates, who thought of him their future shortstop. The statistics web site FanGraphs ranked him as one of baseball’s top prospects, declaring that “there aren’t many who have a chance to be what this guy might.” 

But the accident on a darkened highway threatened to destroy that likelihood earlier than Cruz even made it to the most important leagues. Police detained him on the scene. In a courtroom submitting the next day, prosecutors stated that that they had opened an investigation “en contra del imputado,” “against the accused.” They sought “coercive measures,” a mechanism in Dominican regulation by which a suspect could be compelled to stay in custody whereas an investigation continues. In a press launch, they alleged that Cruz “had consumed alcoholic beverages prior to the accident.” 

The scandal made headlines within the Dominican Republic and the United States, after which, in a matter of days, it evaporated from the general public eye. How that occurred has been unknown, till now.

I’d heard in regards to the Cruz case final yr after I started reporting on the booming trade of “prestamistas,” moneylenders, who exploit main league prospects within the Dominican Republic by getting their undereducated mother and father to surrender sizable parts of their signing bonuses. The case’s disappearance, I used to be instructed, marked the origin story of probably the most dominant prestamista within the nation’s chaotic baseball ecosystem: Santo Caraballo. At the time, Caraballo was an obscure businessman with political connections. He rose to prominence after forming a enterprise partnership with nationwide hero David Ortiz, the retired Boston Red Sox nice who stays an influential determine in Major League Baseball. (In a assertion, Ortiz stated his enterprise relationship with Caraballo “began to come to an end” greater than 18 months in the past.) I wrote about Caraballo’s practices in “The Dominican Baseball Factory.

To learn how Caraballo made the case in opposition to Cruz go away, I interviewed greater than 30 folks within the Dominican Republic. Some have been afraid to speak, however others, primarily members of the family of the victims, have been keen to talk publicly for the primary time. I additionally obtained tons of of pages of beforehand unreported paperwork, together with courtroom data and financial institution receipts, in addition to voice notes. I made quite a few makes an attempt to succeed in Caraballo about his function, together with sending him a abstract of my findings. He by no means responded. 

The Dominican courtroom system offers victims or their households vital enter on whether or not to pursue a prosecution. Caraballo oversaw a marketing campaign to steer the households of the three victims to simply accept money in return for signing paperwork withdrawing all “penal, civil or judicial” claims in opposition to Cruz. 

The effort rescued Cruz’s baseball profession — he’s now the beginning middle fielder for the Pirates — and it launched Caraballo’s. He turned a ubiquitous operator within the sport, feared for the kind of high-powered connections that would make a lethal crash disappear. But for among the victims’ kinfolk, the cash they obtained — roughly $66,000 in whole for the three households — hasn’t lasted almost so long as the harm: six years of unresolved grief, resentment and remorse that they allowed their forgiveness to be bought.

Cruz declined a request for an interview. His lawyer, Amauris Vásquez Disla, referred to as the accident “a profound tragedy for all parties involved, especially the victims’ families.” He went on to say that the courtroom “issued an order of dismissal based on the findings, a legally binding decision that was a lawful resolution of this matter.”

A spokesperson for the Pittsburgh Pirates stated the staff and Cruz “addressed this matter more than six years ago based on the information available and the outcome of the legal proceedings.”

Two people sit on a motorcycle on a street bathed in warm light. Behind them there is a building with posters, one with a photograph of Oneil Cruz. On the sidewalk sits a palm tree.
A poster of Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder Oneil Cruz in Nizao

Yohan and Deby lived in and round a barrio of Sabana Grande de Palenque, generally known as “Sal Si Puedes,” Get Out If You Can. Five miles from Nizao, it’s marked by ruddy grime roads and half-built houses and is separated from the remainder of the city by a deep canal. Some residents need to cross makeshift footbridges to succeed in their entrance doorways. Daniela grew up within the close by village of Juan Baron.

As was the case with Deby and Daniela, Yohan’s mother and father separated when he was younger. His early childhood was spent in a small picket house the place his paternal grandmother took care of him whereas his mom labored in Santo Domingo as a housekeeper. A youngster when his father suffered a stroke, Yohan would convey him blood strain drugs and take him to the seaside to train within the ocean. Yohan labored as an air-con mechanic, telling his dad his objective was to pay for a new roof for his mother’s home in order that it wouldn’t flood each time it rained. He commuted to Santo Domingo on a X1000 bike he had purchased secondhand. In a nation the place it’s frequent to see three or extra folks on a “moto,” the noisy rig was additionally how his buddies bought round.

A white poster board with photos of a person smiling and posing hangs next to a painting of palm trees and the ocean on a concrete wall.
Images of Yohan Saba Mercado in his mom’s home

The better of these buddies was Deby. The third of 4 boys, all right-handed pitchers rising up, he lived in his mom’s immaculate house. After she moved to Chile six years earlier to search out work, Deby spoke along with her each day, updating her on his love life. He had her identify tattooed inside an infinity image on his arm. When he didn’t make a top-level baseball academy, the most typical path to be signed by a main league staff, Deby returned to highschool. At the time of the crash, he was days away from graduating, bagging groceries and caring for his youthful brother.

Deby and Daniela had identified one another since they have been children and, based on their households, had an off-and-on relationship. Videos and pictures of Daniela usually present her dancing and singing. “She never wanted the party to end,” a pal stated. The youngest of 4, she lived along with her mom, who thought of Daniela her finest pal. She was her “chiquita,” or “little girl,” Daniela would remind her mom when she insisted on sitting on her lap. Many nights, they slept in the identical mattress collectively. She had graduated highschool and was taking English lessons in Santo Domingo.

A photo of a man wearing sunglasses and smiling is in an ornate gold frame on a green wall surrounded by other photographs in frames.
A photograph of Deby Beato Charles alongside these of his brothers

Deby, Yohan and Daniela have been in that hopeful, irritating, liberating interval between adolescence and maturity. They had no intention to be out late that September night time, however they have been additionally not going to show down an impromptu plan to social gathering. 

Daniela instructed her mother she was going to fulfill girlfriends on the Nizao River and could be again by early night. It was nonetheless daylight when she recorded herself at an out of doors bar, carrying a purple costume and singing alongside to a salsa music. Nobody was in a rush to return to the stagnant indoors. As for the nation’s 5 p.m. COVID-19 curfew, few younger folks took it critically. In Baní, the closest sizable metropolis, there was a bar known as Escondido, or Hidden, as a result of it served drinks previous curfew. Daniela and a pal recruited Yohan and Deby, who have been house however straightforward to steer to affix. 

At round 11 p.m., based on courtroom data, they have been using on the four-lane freeway heading house. Late at night time, the highway is desolate and poorly lit. Trucks and automobiles howl by at excessive speeds, and accidents are frequent. A safety guard who works at a snack stand throughout from the positioning of the accident instructed me that his boss was killed when a automobile smashed into his enterprise. 

Yohan was on the handlebars, with Daniela and Deby seated behind him. None wore a helmet. A pal on his personal bike was using alongside them. They had simply handed the shuttered snack stand when Cruz rear-ended Yohan’s bike, smashing its rear tire and throwing the three buddies onto the pavement. 

Cruz referred to as 911, based on his legal professionals. A lieutenant from the nationwide police responded to the scene, however his subsequent report, which he filed in courtroom, gives little element in regards to the accident website or investigation that adopted. If there was any forensic evaluation, prosecutors by no means produced it. There is not any point out of whether or not police believed both Yohan or Cruz was driving recklessly or dashing. The report doesn’t point out whether or not the victims have been examined for his or her alcohol ranges. It makes no reference to the second motorcyclist. When I reached him, he stated that the authorities by no means questioned him. He declined to be interviewed additional.

According to the report, Cruz instructed the lieutenant that “en ningun momento,” “at no time,” did he see the bike earlier than colliding with it within the passing lane. He stated it didn’t have lights — an assertion that might later turn out to be a level of rivalry in courtroom. Cruz’s authorized staff filed a photo of the motorcycle that confirmed lacking lights, however it was taken after the accident, when the bike was barely intact. Luis David, Yohan’s brother, instructed me that the bike had working lights within the entrance however not within the rear. 

The day after the accident, tales have been posted on Facebook that included pictures of Yohan, Deby and Daniela mendacity mangled on the freeway as emergency responders tried to save lots of them. On Dominican gossip and information websites, opinions poured forth. Some have been satisfied that Cruz would get preferential therapy. Others predicted that the households of the victims could be looking for a payday. Many asserted that the deceased have been as a lot at fault as Cruz since they have been all out previous curfew.

An empty road with lush green trees and power lines behind it. On the sidewalk is a white cross.
Near the positioning the place Cruz rear-ended Mercado’s bike, killing all three of its passengers

The households of Yohan, Deby and Daniela all knew of the Cruzes. Oneil’s father, Rafael, performed professional ball, first in Japan after which within the Atlanta Braves group till 2009, when he was suspended after testing constructive for steroids. He returned to Nizao, the place he opened a baseball academy. His most promising pupils included Oneil and his brothers, Rafael Jr. and Homer, who performed professional ball within the United States. Oneil was named after Rafael’s favourite ballplayer, New York Yankees outfielder Paul O’Neill. 

Among the Cruzes’ inside circle was Osvaldo Tamarez, a coach generally known as Cabezon, Big Head. He instructed me that within the hours following the accident, when Oneil was nonetheless in custody, he went to see the Cruzes and suggested them to deal with the aftermath of the accident fastidiously. “Cuidado, tu hijo va a ser una figura pública,” Tamarez stated he instructed them. “Your son is going to be a public figure.” According to Tamarez, the Cruzes assigned him to talk with Daniela’s and Deby’s members of the family, a few of whom he knew from baseball. He instructed me that from the start, their focus was on learn how to repay the victims’ households so that they wouldn’t sue and wouldn’t demand that prosecutors pursue the case. An individual near the Cruzes confirmed Tamarez’s account. 

Tamarez stated that one other coach beneficial that Cruzes usher in Santo Caraballo, a businessman he knew from the baseball trade. Among Caraballo’s many firms was a authorized companies agency, though he wasn’t a lawyer. More related, Caraballo had political connections. He was an envoy within the ministry of overseas affairs, a patronage place awarded him 4 years earlier by President Danilo Medina.

Tamarez stated that Caraballo instantly set to work on a number of fronts, together with organizing a authorized staff. But that wasn’t his most vital function. Caraballo’s most vital job was easy, Tamarez instructed me: Fix the issue. 

At Cruz’s preliminary courtroom look, which got here a little greater than two days after the accident, considered one of his attorneys requested to delay the case so his representatives might “in a humane way, seek solutions” for the households and their “material hardships.” The decide postponed the listening to for 2 days. Family members instructed me that Caraballo, or these working with him, had already begun reaching out to them.


The final time Mercedes Garcia noticed her daughter, she had helped Daniela pull the value tags off her purple costume earlier than she went to the river along with her girlfriends. In the times after the accident, Garcia was haunted by a imaginative and prescient of her daughter plastered to the highway within the torn costume, yelling, “Ayúdame Mamá, ayúdame!” “Help me, Mama, help me!”

I discovered Garcia the place she spends a lot of her day: seated alone in her tiny lounge, rocking backwards and forwards on a sofa, her hair neatly pulled again, digging underneath her fingernails with a bobby pin. I might hear the shouts of a girl preaching on the church subsequent door.

A woman in a bright blue shirt wearing glasses looks to her right. Behind her is a couch with a white patterned cloth draped on it and a dinner table.
Mercedes Garcia at house in Juan Baron

Garcia, who’s 65, says she was clear from the start that she didn’t need cash from the Cruzes. “Rich people, especially baseball players, like to pay for dead people with money,” she instructed me. “I am poor, but I have honor.” All she wished, she stated, was for Cruz to reply for what occurred and apologize. Instead, she stated, her household — most prominently, her son — tricked her into agreeing to a deal. 

Garcia instructed me that within the aftermath of her daughter’s demise, she entrusted her son Porfirio with dealing with all of the paperwork. Porfirio was a site visitors cop in Santo Domingo who moonlighted as an Uber driver. What Garcia didn’t know, however what Tamarez later confirmed, was that Porfirio was already working with Caraballo.

According to Garcia, Porfirio introduced her a doc to signal that he partially obscured along with his hand. Shortly afterward, Porfirio drove her and one other of her sons, Juan Manuel, to Caraballo’s workplace in Santo Domingo. Porfirio went in by himself and introduced out one other doc for his mom to signal. She was in a fog of grief, she instructed me, and didn’t learn it. Juan Manuel confirmed his mom’s account that she didn’t perceive what she was signing and that Porfirio didn’t clarify what it was. 

Daniela’s father, Porfirio Perez, co-signed the paperwork. Perez, who can barely learn, parks automobiles at a financial institution for suggestions. He instructed me that Garcia’s brother introduced him the papers however didn’t inform him that they exonerated Cruz. “Because they saw that I’m a simple person, they took advantage of me,” he stated. Garcia’s brother declined to remark. 

I reviewed the 2 paperwork, which have been dated the identical day as Cruz’s courtroom look. One was filed in courtroom by Cruz’s legal professional; the opposite was not. The doc filed in courtroom states that the household sought to “withdraw” all authorized claims in opposition to Cruz. It additionally says that the household had not obtained any “pecuniary interest” in return for withdrawing the claims. They have been doing so out of an consciousness that the accident was not brought on by Cruz, the doc says, “but rather by circumstances of life.” 

The contract not filed in court is signed by Daniela’s mother and father and Oneil’s mom. It’s a “discharge and legal settlement” stating that the mother and father have been paid 900,000 pesos, about $15,000, for Daniela’s “funeral expenses.” That quantity is greater than twice the typical annual revenue within the Dominican Republic. The doc says that the cash represented a settlement for “damages caused” by Cruz to Daniela’s household. But Garcia and Juan Manuel stated that Porfirio managed the payout and that he gave them round 300,000 pesos, or lower than $5,000. Daniela’s father instructed me he obtained nothing.

A grave with a photograph of a young woman smiling on it. Beside her it reads “Daniela Perez Garcia” with an illustration of a cross and a dove.
Daniela Perez Garcia’s grave website

Garcia stated that she didn’t speak to a lot of her household for years after she realized what had occurred. Once they determined to take that cash, they misplaced her, too, she instructed me. “I was buried along with Daniela.” 

I left a number of voice and textual content messages for Porfirio, who declined to be interviewed.

Cruz’s mom, nonetheless, did agree to listen to my questions. I met her on the Cruzes’ gated house on a busy road in Nizao. With cautious politeness, she indicated that we sit on the entrance porch. Batting cages have been within the again. 

I requested her about Caraballo’s function in persuading the victims’ households to not sue, however she denied that she knew him, contradicting a number of witnesses. When I confirmed her a {photograph} of Caraballo, she instructed me she didn’t acknowledge him. Before I might ask my subsequent query, she stood up, making it clear the interview was over. No greater than 5 minutes had handed. “Thank you so much for coming,” she stated. “I can’t really answer because I don’t know anything.”


When Deby’s mom, Elena Charles, left for Chile to search out restaurant work, it fell to Ruben, the eldest of her 4 sons, to take “las riendas de la casa,” the reins of the home. So it was Ruben, who turned 27 the night time his brother died, whom Tamarez visited shortly after Cruz’s courtroom look. Ruben instructed me that Tamarez inspired him to strike a deal, arguing that the ballplayer was by no means going to be punished and that Daniela’s household had already obtained a million pesos for agreeing to not sue. He ought to meet with a man named Caraballo and listen to what he needed to say.

Ruben spoke along with his father, who instructed him the identical factor: Deby was not coming again. Take the cash, even should you simply hold it in an account. (Deby’s father didn’t comply with an interview.)

When Ruben bought to Caraballo’s workplace, he stated Cruz’s mom was there. All he wished, Ruben instructed me, was justice — he didn’t care if the courts administered it or if he did. But he was additionally conscious that Tamarez and his father have been most likely proper: He and his household have been powerless. 

Ruben yelled at Caraballo that he wasn’t there to barter over his brother’s demise prefer it was a automobile on the market. Caraballo, he stated, responded like a man used to folks exploding with rage in his workplace. He identified all of his surveillance cameras. According to Ruben, he then made his provide. Because each of Deby’s mother and father lived outdoors the nation — his father had been in Spain for years — extra authorized work could be required if Ruben’s household made an settlement. Therefore, he was prepared to go as excessive as 2 million pesos, roughly $34,000. 

Deby’s mom returned house a couple of weeks after the accident. I just lately met along with her and her three surviving sons of their comfy and tidy lounge. Fifty-two years outdated, wearing a patterned jumpsuit and a necklace bearing her nickname — Ramonita — she steadily wiped away tears as she mentioned Deby. On the wall have been portraits of every of the boys. Deby’s brothers are carrying their highschool commencement robes. Deby is pictured shirtless, sporting sun shades, ripped denims and a realizing grin. 

As we mentioned the negotiation with Caraballo, Ruben and his mom revisited an argument that appeared as contemporary as these that they had throughout hourslong cellphone calls six years in the past. She was completely clear about what she wished: Cruz needs to be in jail for 120 years.

“Te dije no lo hagas,” she stated to him, her voice rising. “I told you not to do it.” 

“And what did I tell you?” Ruben responded. “That they were going to release him anyway!” 

Ruben signed a doc on behalf of his household referred to as an “act of withdrawal,” which Cruz’s attorneys later filed in courtroom. Similar to the doc signed by Daniela’s mother and father, it attested that Cruz “had not the slightest intention of causing the accident” and that Deby’s household had agreed to withdraw all authorized claims in opposition to him, together with prison and civil, with out “any type of pressure [or] pecuniary interest.” 

Caraballo, although, wasn’t carried out. Ruben instructed me that Caraballo then pitched him on turning his brother’s demise into an revenue alternative: Rather than give the household the two million pesos in a lump sum, Caraballo would make investments the cash for them and pay 15,000 pesos, simply over $265, a month indefinitely. 

Ruben, although, was carried out with Caraballo. “I don’t want to do business with you,” he stated he instructed him, “and I don’t want to hear from you ever again.”

The household put the cash in a checking account. Except for the curiosity, roughly $65 a month, which the household has used to assist pay for the youngest’s tuition, the cash remains to be there, they instructed me. Charles defined that there’s been loads of occasions that they might’ve dipped into the principal, however the cash repels her. “It doesn’t have an end,” she stated of the anguish she feels about having made a cope with the Cruzes. “For the rest of my life, it’s going to be a conflict.”


Genny Mercado, after turning away the driving force with Cruz’s mom on the road, confronted a related gantlet of strain from her household. Word unfold that the opposite households have been accepting a deal. Genny earned about 16,000 pesos, about $275, a month as a housekeeper, so a settlement would doubtless exceed a number of years of revenue. Rejecting the cash, Yohan’s half brothers instructed her, would accomplish nothing. 

Mercado, who’s 48, was additionally the de facto decision-maker. Yohan’s father, Pedro Saba, had suffered a second stroke the day he discovered of his son’s demise. She employed the one lawyer she knew, who negotiated a deal on the mother and father’ behalf. The doc was a withdrawal like these signed by the opposite households, exonerating Cruz. Mercado stated that she couldn’t assume clearly about any of this on the time: “My mind was set on my son.” 

Minus the lawyer’s minimize, Mercado and Saba obtained roughly 800,000 pesos, or $14,000. Yohan’s father spent 300,000 pesos on a fridge, a tv and a mattress. Mercado used the cash to purchase rebar and 75 baggage of cement to construct the roof that Yohan had promised. She stopped working for seven months and barely left her house besides to place flowers on his grave.

When I confirmed up, two of her sons organized plastic chairs in the lounge so I might converse along with her and her husband, José Enrique. She had by no means been interviewed, and it had been years since anybody outdoors the household even pretended to care about what occurred to Yohan. “Any family that goes through something like this just wants justice,” Mercado instructed me. “Everyone who kills has to go to jail.” But in Cruz’s case, “No one wanted to hurt the future del muchacho.”

Two young men stand behind a woman, all looking at the camera. Behind them is a bright living room with colorful flowers and paintings.
Genny Mercado, Yohan’s mom, with two of her sons, Eduardo (left) and Yeri

There have been no second ideas about having accepted the cash, solely resignation that there was by no means going to be a honest final result for Yohan. “Around here, the police let a lot of things slide, especially when it involves people who have money or connections or whatever else,” stated José Enrique, tossing shucked pea shells on the cement flooring. “We’re not going to try to dance around that fact anymore.”

Later I visited Yohan’s father, who spends his days in a spartan house with three of his aged brothers, two of whom are blind. “Terminator” blared on the tv. Saba doesn’t have any pictures of Yohan on his partitions as a result of, he stated, it might make him too unhappy. In a voice slurred by his two strokes, Saba instructed me how Yohan would put him on his bike and take him to the ocean. “Wherever I wanted to go,” he stated, “he would take me there.” He hasn’t been again to the seaside since Yohan was killed.


Cruz’s second courtroom date occurred on the Friday following the accident. Prosecutors have been looking for to maintain him in custody for 3 months. The victims’ households weren’t current. The courtroom didn’t know learn how to attain two of them, a clerk defined to the decide. Prosecutors didn’t even get the names of the victims proper, referring to Yohan Saba as “Jons Sabab” and Deby as “Baby.” The prices they sought in opposition to Cruz included reckless driving and inflicting an accident that resulted in demise. If convicted, he might face one to 3 years in jail. 

Most placing was what was not stated. In their press launch after the crash, prosecutors had referred to proof that Cruz had been consuming earlier than the accident. But they by no means made that declare in courtroom. I reached out to the lead prosecutor in addition to the prosecutor’s workplace to ask why that they had determined to not cost Cruz with driving whereas intoxicated. Both declined to remark. A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette journalist requested the identical query the week of the courtroom date. He reported that a spokesperson for the prosecutors defined that Cruz had “smelled of alcohol” after the accident however that police hadn’t carried out a sobriety check due to a “procedural error.” 

While Cruz remained in police custody, his authorized staff submitted the withdrawals that had been signed by the victims’ households. In addition to providing his condolences, an legal professional defined that Cruz was offering “material support” to the households for his or her “basic needs of being human: education, food, clothing, among other matters.” He additionally submitted quite a few testimonials praising Cruz’s good character, together with from his pastor, who attested that Cruz had demonstrated “loyalty and absolute fidelity to the gospel,” and from a native marble and granite contractor who stated that Cruz was a accountable shopper “deserving of an open line of credit.” The legal professional emphasised that Cruz was considered one of baseball’s “five highest-rated prospects internationally.”

The accident, he instructed the decide, “hurts the whole town, Oneil above all, who for this will have to go to professional therapy so that he can cope with the trauma … For God’s sake, let’s try to ensure that Oneil Cruz Ureña’s mental health is now a priority.” 

Four men pose together around an airport utility cart, featuring social media handle overlays and a music tag for “Mera Woo” by El Alfa.
A social media submit made a few weeks after Cruz’s launch exhibits him (second from left), alongside Caraballo (far left) and two others on the Miami airport. Instagram

The decide launched Cruz on a bond of two million pesos, or $34,000. A few weeks later, Cruz posted a picture of himself with Caraballo, grinning whereas seated on a golf cart on the Miami airport. 

The following March, Cruz was on the Pirates’ spring coaching facility in Florida. An article on the time talked about the accident in passing, buried underneath the information that the staff was transferring him into the outfield. It’s the one time I do know of through which Cruz has been quoted discussing the accident.

“In the beginning, I was very fearful of not being able to continue to play the game that I love and to reach the dream I’ve always had, which is to reach the big leagues,” Cruz stated by way of an interpreter. “However, when things became clear later and everything was solved, I was able to … hope again that I’ll be able to play. Now, I have peace.”

The press, each within the United States and the Dominican Republic, stopped protecting the accident after that. 

The man who helped ship him that peace used the incident to turn out to be one of the highly effective figures working within the shadows of Dominican baseball.

A man in a Pittsburgh uniform and helmet has a baseball bat under his arm. He is adjusting his gloves. Behind him are the bright lights of a stadium and a dark sky.
Oneil Cruz, now the middle fielder for the Pittsburgh Pirates Andy Kuno/San Francisco Giants/Getty Images

Cruz’s subsequent courtroom look was Aug. 30, 2021. Almost a yr had handed for the reason that accident, and he was within the States enjoying for the Altoona Curve, a Pirates minor league staff. He attended nearly. Despite the households’ withdrawals, prosecutors nonetheless had the facility to pursue prices in opposition to him, however their case was flimsy. The solely proof they submitted have been demise certificates and a police report that supplied little greater than the date and time of the accident and the names of Cruz and the three folks he killed: Yohan Saba Mercado, Deby Beato Charles and Daniela Perez Garcia. The decide dismissed the case, ordering the return of the two million pesos bond. 

Just over a month later, Cruz made his main league debut in opposition to the Cincinnati Reds, scorching a single that was the hardest recorded hit by a Pirate, a mark he has broken many times since. He is now a fixture of the staff and can earn $3.3 million this yr. He is projected to make way more as soon as he turns into a free agent in a few seasons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *