Week 12 Game Day Kickoff: Appreciating Jeremiah Smith
Depending on the attitude via which you view the 2026 season up to now, it’s both a clear-cut case for why playoff enlargement to 24 groups is a necessity or why it is an absolute travesty.
On the one hand, there is a dearth of groups that look to be true championship contenders. If we set the bar for what a playoff workforce ought to appear like after 10 video games as a power-conference college with three or fewer losses or a one-loss workforce from the Group of 6, our mixed tally is simply 24.
That’s lower than some other 12 months of the playoff period. It’s 10 fewer than last year.
Or let’s actually decrease the bar. How many groups have not more than three losses, none of which got here towards a workforce at present outdoors the FPI prime 40, and no less than one win vs. an FPI top-25 workforce? Answer: 13.
Or how about this one: Last 12 months, Notre Dame was the primary workforce unnoticed of the playoff. Its FPI at this level within the 2025 season was 22.4. How many groups are higher than that immediately? Six. The level is, in the event you’re on the lookout for nice, it is slim pickings.
But what in the event you’re simply on the lookout for “interesting”? Because if the 24-team playoff is not doubtless to offer us with a cadre of recent title contenders, it definitely goes to open the door to much more late-season video games with important import within the battle for spots 21, 22, 23 and 24.
Take, for instance, the lackluster slate of Week 12 this 12 months. ESPN’s “College GameDay” is headed to Miami to witness the Hurricanes wallop a Virginia Tech workforce that simply misplaced by 18 to Stanford. Fox’s “Big Noon Kickoff” is touring to Division II Ferris State for its first-round playoff recreation towards Truman State.
But what if we had the 24-team playoff already? Suddenly the snooze-fest of Week 12 turns into as deep because the snow drifts within the car parking zone of a Syracuse Walmart.
Right now, SMU‘s journey to Notre Dame is all however meaningless. The Mustangs had been whipped by Wake Forest final week, and regardless of a 7-3 file, did not crack the committee’s prime 25. But beat Notre Dame on the street and SMU’s case for a spot within the 24-team playoff turns into an intriguing debate.
Right now, Kentucky‘s recreation at Missouri is a showdown between two as soon as enjoyable tales which have unraveled just like the latter seasons of “How I Met Your Mother,” the place many of the viewers is simply hanging on to see how Ted finds the mom or how Eli Drinkwitz finds a brand new job. But within the 24-team playoff period, it is a big matchup — a recreation that places the winner in place to host a house recreation and places the loser on the skin wanting in.
Right now, LSU–Tennessee is successfully relegated to a hate watch, the place essentially the most attention-grabbing query is how a lot decrease Lane Kiffin can go. He already has 4 losses and is dropping F-bombs in information conferences, and his unhealthy angle throughout his morning yoga classes is ruining everybody’s chi. The Tigers are down unhealthy sufficient that it hardly appears price it for Tennessee followers to pelt him with golf balls and mustard packets. But in a 24-team playoff, fireplace away!
The identical narrative is true for South Carolina, which the committee has absolved of all sins dedicated towards Arkansas due to LaNorris Sellers‘ harm, now with an opportunity to make a press release by knocking off No. 1.
Oregon, Oklahoma and Texas A&M might have main playoff implications in a 24-team format, too. Instead, we’ll watch the Sooners and Aggies commerce punts and destroy what little stays of their QBs’ as soon as spectacular legacies for nothing.
This is the tradeoff we get by increasing the postseason. On one hand, it has watered down what it means to be a playoff workforce, and it has taken little bit of the shine off what had appeared like do-or-die matchups akin to final week’s Texas-LSU thriller. On the opposite hand, increasing playoff entry means there’d be a motive to look at Illinois host Iowa this week apart from dropping a wager or being a member of Hank Brown’s fast household.
Whether turning late-season video games between a few four-loss groups right into a de facto play-in recreation constitutes progress is a type of “eye of the beholder” issues, however what’s inarguable is that handing out a couple of extra participation trophies would no less than make sure the penultimate Saturday of faculty soccer’s common season would have loads of video games with no less than as a lot cachet because the one that includes groups from Kirksville, Missouri, and Big Rapids, Michigan.
Jump to:
Top games | Under the radar
Upset alert | Power rankings
Heisman five | Two-minute drill

Best of the remainder of Week 12
Let’s take a second to completely admire the greatness of Jeremiah Smith. Last week, he set a Big Ten file along with his seventeenth 100-yard recreation. To put that into perspective, previously decade, all Iowa gamers mixed have 16 100-yard video games.
But let’s not fear an excessive amount of about profession numbers. Let’s deal with what Smith, extensively understood to be the most effective receiver within the nation with double-teams galore and now with an injured QB, has executed these days.
Smith leads the nation with 25 contested catches. That’s seven greater than some other Power 4 participant. The margin between Smith and No. 2 on the checklist is identical because the margin from No. 2 to No. 13. Just eight different Power 4 gamers have half as many as he is bought.
Or how about this: Smith has 58 catches which have gone for a primary down or landing. That’s 13 greater than some other Power 4 receiver, and the margin between him and No. 2 is identical because the margin between No. 2 and No. 23. If he solely had these catches that went for a primary down or landing, Smith would nonetheless lead the Power 4 in receiving yards.
Smith is magical, no matter his QB.
Nebraska has its personal sort of magic, although. It in some way manages to noticed itself in half and make its followers disappear by the fourth quarter each time it performs a ranked foe. The Huskers have misplaced 31 straight towards ranked foes, and to snap the streak this week, they’re going to have to hold Smith in verify. So, go forward and mark it down as 32.
In the previous two weeks, Miami has confronted off towards two top-25 passing defenses with out its greatest receiver, Heisman contender Malachi Toney.
In these two video games, towards Notre Dame and Duke, Darian Mensah has nonetheless thrown for 686 yards, 4 touchdowns and only one choose, with 10 completions of 20 yards or extra, and averaged practically 8 yards per cross.
Perhaps as an alternative of Toney’s harm derailing Mensah’s Heisman marketing campaign, it clarified it. The Miami QB is a famous person — with or with out Toney.
This week, Mensah will get a Virginia Tech secondary that ranks 103rd in opponent passer ranking, 106th in yards-per-pass allowed, and has surrendered 91 factors to SMU and Stanford previously two weeks.
UCLA‘s protection ranks No. 2 within the nation in success price vs. FBS opponents (66.9%). Michigan‘s is No. 6 (62.6%).
UCLA’s protection ranks thirteenth in explosive play price (9.08%), whereas Michigan’s ranks fourth (7.62%).
UCLA’s protection ranks third nationally in factors per drive allowed (1.11), and Michigan’s ranks twentieth (1.53).
UCLA’s D is third in SP+. Michigan’s is seventh.
We might hold going however this has already gone on longer than any Wolverines drive will Saturday.
Are we, as a society, ready for the eventuality of Tommy Castellanos beginning a College Football Playoff recreation? It’s an nearly unimaginable notion to completely grasp, however the odds are stacked in his favor.
After successful in court docket — then dropping, then successful once more — he has taken over the beginning job from Will Hammond at Texas Tech, and the outcomes have been spectacular. In his previous three video games as starter, he has tallied 1,026 complete yards, 12 touchdowns and only one turnover, and is averaging higher than 10 yards per cross. Between this and Florida State successful its first two street video games in three years after he bought fired, it has been a tough few weeks for Mike Norvell.
Under-the-radar video games
Wake Forest has overwhelmed its previous six opponents by no less than 24 factors every and received its previous 4 by a mixed rating of 218-21.
Next up: arguably the worst workforce within the Power 4 not named Maryland.
This one might get ugly towards Georgia Tech, however there’s one thing inherently enjoyable about watching the Deacons totally eviscerate an opponent — like Roger Ebert reviewing “North” or Jimmy Sexton negotiating new contracts throughout a Tennessee teaching search. There’s a sure degree of reassurance in seeing the actually nice ones remind us all that there’s an order to issues.
The winner of this one will get a bowl bid. For Virginia, that is not precisely a praise. A 12 months after successful 11 video games and making it to the ACC championship recreation, the Cavaliers have collapsed, stumbling to the end line of a disappointing season.
For North Carolina, alternatively, being 5-5 after 10 video games ranks someplace between discovering $20 within the pocket of an outdated coat and Costco having free samples of these Swedish meatballs on the size of nice surprises. With Freddie Kitchens, Michael Lombardi and Steve Belichick all gone earlier than the season started, and Jordon Hudson returning Bill Belichick’s texts with “New phone, who dis?” Carolina has performed with a degree of competency few believed potential. Even the losses — to Clemson by eight, Notre Dame by 11, Syracuse by one, Miami by three and Louisville by two — have been reminders that UNC belongs on the sphere with anybody.
Will that translate to a different 12 months in Chapel Hill for Belichick? The jury is clearly nonetheless out, as UNC president Lee Roberts stated there was no speak of an extension for the six-time Super Bowl winner. But a win towards Virginia and a bowl recreation assure will surely make a transparent forged that the ship is headed in the fitting path.
How powerful is it to fill out a top-25 poll nowadays?
Houston has misplaced two of its previous three video games, together with arguably the ugliest lack of the 12 months by a ranked workforce final week towards Colorado. Its lone win in that span was by a landing over a slumping Cincinnati. It has been greater than a month because the Cougars received a recreation by double digits. Back then, Houston was 5-1 and the No. 20 workforce within the nation.
Now, Houston is ranked … twentieth.
The Cougars are principally like Buster Keaton with the home falling down round him as he stands there, unaware, in precisely the fitting place to stay unhurt.
But do not rely on that luck persevering with in Week 12. A street journey to (*12*) is rarely simple, however given Houston’s struggling protection, Michael Hawkins — the FBS chief with 20 dashing touchdowns — might have a area day, thus dropping Houston all the best way to No. 22 within the rankings.
Upset alert
New Mexico’s playoff hopes already took an enormous hit final week with a loss to UNLV, and issues might worsen in Week 12. Wyoming has received 5 straight and is 4-0 at residence this 12 months, and it has a sophomore working again named Samuel “Tote” Harris, who has 194 yards dashing and three touchdowns the previous two weeks. That’s numerous good mojo within the Cowboys’ favor.
There are simply 5 of the Big Ten’s 18 groups which have had the identical beginning QB for all 10 video games this season. Minnesota is one in every of them. (USC, Nebraska, Purdue and Penn State are the others.) And whereas it is good that no less than one outstanding Minnesota soccer workforce has some QB certainty, the Gophers would nonetheless in all probability love to have the ability to commerce for Kirk Cousins, too. Drake Lindsey has gone 5 straight video games with out finishing 60% of his passes, his 6.1 yards-per-attempt ranks 123rd amongst certified QBs, and his 43.0 Total QBR is the fifth worst amongst certified Power 4 passers. Still, life is not precisely higher for Northwestern, which has dropped three straight. Slight edge right here to Minnesota for no less than shaking issues up by firing offensive coordinator Greg Harbaugh Jr.

NC State employed former QB Philip Rivers as its new coach, and whereas he will not be working the present for this 12 months’s workforce, he has no less than introduced some new vitality to Raleigh as NC State tries to rally to make a bowl recreation. Florida State, in the meantime, has received its final two, placing the Seminoles one win away from attending to a bowl for the primary time since 2023 with interim coach Rick Stockstill. Unfortunately, there are guidelines about FSU having good issues, and whereas we could not agree with it, we’re pressured to abide by them.
Post-Week 11 energy rankings
A glance again on the largest movers and shakers from final week’s motion.
1. Alabama, which overcame a tricky SEC street opponent regardless of not enjoying its greatest. That’s the signal of a real champion.
2. Clemson, the place all the things is okay based on the canine sipping espresso amid an inferno
3. Wake Forest
4. Interviewing Brian Kelly
5. Left-for-dead Arch Manning (once more!)
6. Bill Belichick wanting like a bouncer from “Road House”
7. Stanford
8. Arizona shifting up 4 spots within the CFP Top 25 after a loss
9. Firing your OC
10. Getting revenge on groups for delaying a recreation due to journey points
Not ranked: Getting revenge on Mario Cristobal, connecting flights, Lane Kiffin, second-half Cal, wholesome Big Ten QBs
Heisman 5
We’re closing in on the tip of the season, and the contenders — the practical ones anyway — appear fairly clear. Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah, Gunner Stockton, Devon Dampier and CJ Carr make up the checklist, with maybe some long-shot choices akin to Gio Lopez, Nate Sheppard or, sure, Arch Manning nonetheless technically within the combine.
1:09
Manny Diaz makes the case for Nate Sheppard to be a Heisman finalist
But for this week’s rating, we wished to go off the board fully and rank our prime 5 gamers getting zero Heisman love who need to be within the dialog because the nation’s greatest school soccer participant.
1. Utah LT Zereoue Williams
Dampier is getting numerous much-deserved consideration for main the Utes to a 10-0 file and the No. 2 rating within the nation, however his success is available in no small half on account of the astounding work being executed up entrance by the Utah offensive line. And nobody on that line has been greater than Williams. For the season, Williams has allowed simply two pressures, no sacks and blown two run blocks. He has simply three complete blown blocks all 12 months. No different full-time Power 4 left sort out has fewer than seven, and solely three have fewer than 10. In 621 snaps, he has been referred to as for zero holds and only one false begin. Williams is working at one other degree from some other O-lineman within the nation, and he has been the cream to Dampier’s Mountain Dew that has made Utah’s offense so soiled.
This week: Utah travels to TCU seeking to stay undefeated.
2. Clemson CB Ashton Hampton
There are two methods of wanting on the state of affairs at Clemson proper now. There’s Dabo Swinney’s view that the Tigers have some good items and are however a few plays away from being 6-2. It is an effective workforce that has the potential for greatness, and with somewhat extra time, it is all going to work itself out. Then there’s the attitude that actually each different human on Earth agrees to be true: Clemson is a practice wreck with an engineer nonetheless attempting to pilot the practice farther off the tracks. In both case, Hampton has been a pleasant silver lining. He has allowed completions on simply 26.8% of his targets, the second-best price nationally amongst cornerbacks, hasn’t allowed a landing and has given up only one completion of greater than 10 yards all season, has a pair of interceptions and ranks third nationally with 12 cross breakups. Opposing passers have a 0.8 QBR when focusing on him this season. And take into account he has been capable of do all this regardless of not attending to pad his stat sheet towards Clemson’s quarterbacks.
This week: Clemson visits Duke, the place Sheppard might throw for extra yardage than the Tigers do.
3. Toledo DE Andrew Zock
The statistical case for Zock is outstanding. He has racked up 17 tackles for loss and 11.5 sacks, each good for second within the nation, an FBS-best 31 tackles at or behind the road of scrimmage, 30 solo tackles (third amongst FBS D-linemen) and — look forward to it — 57 pressures, 13 greater than some other defensive lineman within the nation. But there is a extra emotional, extra related case, too. It’s actually enjoyable to say “Zock.”
This week: Toledo hosts Bowling Green with no less than a flicker of hope for the Group of 6’s playoff spot remaining.
4. Iowa State RB Aiden Flora
The Cyclones’ roster was decimated when Matt Campbell left for Penn State, however Flora, who had simply 15 carries in his profession, caught round. Iowa State is glad he did. The Cyclones are actually one win away from getting bowl eligible, and Flora is the largest motive why. He leads the nation in dashing with 1,335 yards, and he is third in yards per carry (7.22) amongst backs with no less than 100 totes. He has gone for 200 yards in three of his previous six video games, and he has racked up 735 all-purpose yards over his previous three.
This week: Iowa State travels to UCF earlier than wrapping the season with Kansas State. A win in both will imply bowl eligibility, and a win in each can be the primary time Iowa State had seven regular-season victories underneath a coach apart from Campbell since 2005.
5. FAU WR Easton Messer
Fun reality: Messer has 13 receiving touchdowns, two dashing touchdowns, two punt return touchdowns and a passing landing this 12 months. The final time any FBS participant had no less than 18 complete TDs, and one every receiving, dashing, passing and as a returner, was Saquon Barkley in 2017, and the one different participant to do it with a punt return (relatively than a kickoff return) previously 20 years was Clemson’s C.J. Spiller in 2009. That’s some elite firm for a man who started his profession as a walk-on at Western Kentucky.
This week: FAU hosts USF in a battle to find out American Conference hierarchy within the state of Florida. Both are 6-4.
Two-minute drill
It has been some time since we have been capable of escape this stat, however fortunately on the penultimate weekend of the common season, the SEC gives a full slate of FCS matchups to make it related as soon as once more: Power 4 groups are 55-0 towards FCS opponents this 12 months, successful by a median of 46 factors per recreation. Just two have been inside 10 factors within the fourth quarter at any level. Twelve have been determined by 60 or extra. Last 12 months, the FCS was 0-60 vs. Power 4 groups. In 2024, it was 0-58. In 2023, it was 1-53 with the lone victory coming from Sacramento State towards a woeful Stanford workforce. Sacramento State is now an FBS member.
And but this week, we’ll see Ole Miss show it deserves its top-25 rating by internet hosting Wofford. Alabama will definitely validate the committee’s No. 3 rating with an enormous residence recreation towards Chattanooga. Mississippi State can lastly break its six-game dropping streak if it could in some way survive Tennessee Tech. And Auburn hosts Samford in a recreation Alex Golesh certainly dreamed of teaching when he was a boy in Russia with little greater than a dusty outdated transistor radio, a couple of turnips and a imaginative and prescient of sooner or later tasting the glory of beating the sixth-best workforce within the Southern Conference.
It’s time to make it cease. The committee could have a tough sufficient job determining who belongs in a 24-team playoff area subsequent 12 months. The job does not must be made tougher by throwing away one in every of 12 knowledge factors on a recreation that may accomplish nothing apart from getting a key participant damage.
With backup Grant Wilson at QB, Indiana toppled USC 27-13 final week. Wilson threw for 305 yards and two scores within the victory. It’s essentially the most the Hoosiers have scored in a recreation since early October towards Rutgers and marked the primary time Indiana threw for 300 yards in a recreation since beating Wisconsin final November. Even wilder, it is the primary time an Indiana QB has thrown for 300 yards in a win over a power-conference foe with a successful file since Connor Bazelak in 2022.
Why does this really feel like the right likelihood for Arch Manning to finish 52% of his throws for 106 yards and two unhealthy picks, however join on a late TD to Cam Coleman to shut out an totally forgettable 24-10 Texas win?
Vanderbilt has simply 9 passing touchdowns all season. Three of them got here towards NC State. What are the chances that would not be essentially the most embarrassing a part of that efficiency for the Wolfpack? Oddly, Vandy won’t be the workforce with greater QB points on this one. Florida‘s passers over the previous 5 video games have thrown simply three touchdowns and 7 interceptions, whereas averaging only a tick greater than 5 air yards per throw.
Calvin Russell III tore an Achilles on March 30. Just 230 days later — final Saturday, to be exact — he caught 17 passes in a win over NC State. That’s a genuinely exceptional restoration that ought to be studied by medical doctors, scientists and perhaps Gerry McNamara, who might in all probability use one other small ahead. Russell’s efficiency marks simply the second time previously 20 years an ACC participant had 17 catches in a single convention recreation. The different was additionally a Syracuse receiver (Ervin Phillips) in 2017… additionally towards NC State.
Old Dominion has surrendered 44 sacks this season, essentially the most within the FBS. How unhealthy is that? In the playoff period, there are solely 9 different examples of an FBS workforce permitting no less than 44 sacks via 10 video games. The actually wild factor although is 2 of the opposite examples are additionally Old Dominion. In 2019, the Monarchs had allowed 45 sacks at this level, and in 2023, they’d given up 52. And it will get worse. It’s not simply the QB taking a beating within the backfield. ODU has had 135 runs stopped at or behind the road of scrimmage this 12 months — 37.7% of its complete run performs. That’s 23 greater than some other FBS workforce. The distinction between the Monarchs and the next-worst workforce (West Virginia) is identical because the distinction between WVU and No. 28. Surely there are just a few heavyset dudes with surly attitudes wandering round Norfolk, Virginia, that Old Dominion might signal and ask to only stand in entrance of some defenders for a few video games, proper?


























