Should the Phillies hit Brandon Marsh leadoff more?

Tuesday evening’s recreation featured a brand new look lineup out of necessity, as Trea Turner was nonetheless sore from getting hit by a pitch Monday evening and didn’t play. So, the lineup featured Brandon Marsh main off and Kyle Schwarber hitting second whereas enjoying first base.

Needless to say, the lineup labored effectively that evening, because it totaled 8 runs on 6 hits together with house runs from Marsh, Schwarber, and Alec Bohm. Marsh particularly stood out in his first time main off this 12 months, going 1-3 with a two-run homer, a stroll, and a stolen base. It’s not a really perfect lineup, as Marsh main off meant that there have been three consecutive left-handers at the high of the lineup in Marsh, Schwarber, and Bryce Harper. It possible will not be capable to occur towards left-handed starters and it is a potential legal responsibility late in video games when groups can deploy lefties out of the bullpen, but it surely is perhaps the finest 1-2-3 the Phillies can discipline proper now contemplating Turner’s struggles.

In an ideal world, Turner is hitting both first or second and serving to to interrupt up the run of left-handers. But he is been one among the worst hitters in baseball whereas Marsh has been one among the finest. Turner’s damage supplied a glimpse into what a shift in the lineup may appear to be, and in a single pattern it was a rousing success. But when Turner returned on Wednesday, he went again to hit leadoff and picked up three hits, his first multi-hit recreation since June seventh.

Clearly, the Phillies and Don Mattingly choose Marsh hitting behind Harper deeper in the lineup. Still, it is onerous to disregard that Marsh is healthier fitted to leadoff proper now than Turner. SW, ought to the Phillies hit Brandon Marsh leadoff extra?