NFL’s first week of free agency winners and losers: The QB carousel was just as bad as everyone thought for some teams

The recreation of quarterback musical chairs was at all times going to get ugly. There have been much more chairs within the recreation than competent quarterbacks to fill them.

And just a couple of days into free agency, some teams should be questioning what to do.

commercial

The Miami Dolphins someway labored across the file lifeless wage cap hit from Tua Tagovailoa to signal Malik Willis, who grew to become essentially the most enticing possibility by far. He obtained $67.5 million over three years with just six NFL begins to his title, which tells you the way tough the quarterback market was.

At least the Dolphins obtained somebody. Many teams are speaking themselves into a lot much less enticing choices.

The Arizona Cardinals do not have anybody. The Cleveland Browns do not both, and appear more likely to discuss themselves into one other season of Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders. Or perhaps it is Deshaun Watson.

The New York Jets obtained a quarterback. They traded for Geno Smith, who was booed out of Las Vegas throughout his horrible time as the Raiders’ starter.

commercial

The Pittsburgh Steelers appear to be hoping that Aaron Rodgers, who will flip 43 subsequent season, performs once more. The Steelers mentioned the state of affairs will not play out like final season once they have been ready seemingly endlessly for a solution, however free agency began and there hasn’t been a call. And the Steelers are one other staff in bad form if Rodgers, who was just respectable final season and is at an age by which solely Tom Brady has had any distant stage of success, steps away from the NFL.

The Atlanta Falcons and Minnesota Vikings wanted quarterbacks to again up, or perhaps change, shaky younger starters. The Falcons landed Tua Tagovailoa and the Vikings will signal Kyler Murray. The Dolphins determined they’d slightly take a $99 million lifeless cap hit than spend any extra time with Tagovailoa, and the Cardinals made the identical selection with a $54.7 million lifeless cap hit on Murray. And, comparatively talking, the Falcons and Vikings have been winners within the QB carousel as a result of they picked up two gamers whose earlier teams spent a small fortune to easily get them off the roster. It’s powerful on the market.

Kirk Cousins ​​will present a bridge for one of these teams, however that is not thrilling. There’s a purpose the Colts held onto Daniel Jones for expensive life. There will probably be some large quarterback conditions on Week 1 of this NFL season, and that is earlier than accidents roll in.

commercial

The unstated half of some of these strikes, significantly with the Cardinals, Jets and Browns, is that they’re ready on the 2027 NFL Draft. This yr’s draft would not have many thrilling prospects exterior of Fernando Mendoza, however subsequent yr it ought to supply a number of quarterbacks who go within the first spherical. Some teams are leaving their choices open till then. That’s a viable technique, however it’s going to be ugly for a yr. It’s powerful to lose hope for the upcoming season in mid-March. But there weren’t sufficient good quarterbacks to go round.

Here are the winners and losers from the first week of free agency (we had a full breakdown of the Maxx Crosby/Trey Hendrickson controversy earlier this week):

WINNERS

Running backs: Relatively talking, it hasn’t been a bad offseason for operating backs.

commercial

Kenneth Walker III and Travis Etienne Jr. are excellent RBs however not essentially within the elite tier. Still, they have been paid effectively for their place. Etienne obtained $52 million over 4 years from the Saints and Walker obtained slightly greater than $43 million over three years from the Chiefs. Kenneth Gainwell (to the Buccaneers), Rico Dowdle (to the Steelers) and Tyler Allgeier (to the Cardinals) all signed two-year offers value greater than $6 million per season. None of the three have been starters final season.

David Montgomery switched teams, going to the Houston Texans for offensive lineman Juice Scruggs, a 2026 fourth-round decide and a 2027 seventh-round decide, which is an efficient haul for the Lions.

Even Chris Rodriguez Jr., who regarded good at occasions with the Washington Commanders final season, obtained $10 million over two years from the Jacksonville Jaguars. That’s not bad for a rusher coming off a 500-yard season.

All in all, it wasn’t a bad week for operating backs.

Klint Kubiak and Robert Saleh: The two teams that spent essentially the most, in phrases of complete contracts, over the first 24 official hours of free agency have been the Titans ($294.5 million) and Raiders ($281.6 million), according to Spotrac. Only one different staff, the Commanders at $233.8 million, have been even over $200 million.

commercial

The earlier head coaches of the Raiders and Titans should be questioning the place that spending was once they have been in cost.

The infusion of expertise into two of the NFL’s worst rosters will assist new coaches Kubiak and Saleh. Kubiak is a rookie head coach, and will nonetheless add quarterback Fernando Mendoza with the first decide of the draft. He is not being frolicked to dry as he begins his head teaching profession. Saleh is making an attempt to show that his shedding profession file is the Jets’ fault by doing higher with the Titans in his second head teaching job. His roster, significantly on protection, was remade with 13 additions, essentially the most within the NFL within the early portion of free agency. Both coaches obtained lots of assist as free agency started.

Los Angeles Rams, your favourite Super Bowl: Rams basic supervisor Les Snead had a better job this offseason than many of his colleagues. He already had a improbable roster, and he did not have any key gamers about to hit free agency.

Still credit score Snead for doing his job as utterly as anybody to start out free agency.

The Rams appeared like they have been a pair of cornerbacks away from not having any clear weak spot. That was their solely obvious want. So Snead obtained aggressive, as he has finished up to now. He has traded the twenty ninth total decide on this yr’s draft, a fifth-round and sixth-round decide on this yr’s draft and a 2027 third-round decide to the Chiefs for Trent McDuffie, one of the NFL’s greatest cornerbacks. That’s expensive (additionally contemplate the $124 million extension they gave him), nevertheless it’s extremely unlikely on this unexciting draft that the twenty ninth decide will have an effect like McDuffie, for a staff that has Super Bowl goals.

commercial

Then the Rams doubled up on Chiefs cornerbacks, signing Jaylen Watson to a three-year, $51 million deal.

LA was already good, however wanted cornerbacks. It mounted that, and nonetheless held onto the thirteenth total decide of the draft. It’s Super Bowl or bust now for the Rams.

LOSERS

George Pickens: Pickens ought to imagine he is a greater receiver than Alec Pierce. He had extra receptions, yards and touchdowns than Pierce final season. They’re each 25 years outdated.

But Pickens obtained the franchise tag, and Pierce did not.

Pierce cashed in on his greatest NFL season with a four-year deal that may be value as much as $116 million. That’s $29 million a yr for Pierce if it reaches its peak. Pickens obtained tagged. The franchise tag is for one yr at $27.3 million.

commercial

That’s lots of cash. But it is also $88.7 million lower than Pierce obtained. It’s not even the identical in phrases of common per yr. There’s no higher illustration for why the union must do one thing to get rid of the franchise tag. There’s a purpose gamers hate it.

Quiet teams, perhaps: As ordinary, NFL free agency hadn’t even formally began and most of the league had dedicated many tens of millions to gamers in the course of the contact interval with pending free brokers.

Almost each staff added assist, which made it appear bad for the few golf equipment that did not participate within the first wave. But perhaps these teams are value following.

commercial

[Draft your Yahoo Fantasy Baseball team for the 2026 MLB Season]

The closing 4 teams that hadn’t been added to an outdoor free agent have been the Broncos, Eagles, Seahawks and Jaguars. Those 4 teams have been the final two Super Bowl champions, a staff that was the No. 1 seed within the AFC final season and a staff that gained the AFC South final season. Maybe they’re the teams everyone else must be following?

There are cap causes for the relative inactivity early on for these 4 teams, nevertheless it’s additionally straightforward to take a look at the record of large contracts being handed out and perceive that nearly each one was an overpay. There’s no means round that in free agency. Four of the most effective teams from final season, some of whom are among the many most revered organizations within the sport, sat out that half of free agency. That is perhaps telling.

JJ McCarthy: After 10 begins for the Minnesota Vikings, the McCarthy period appears near lifeless.

commercial

The Vikings made it pretty clear that they needed a brand new quarterback, very doubtless as a Week 1 starter. They appeared to have him in Kyler Murray, who signed with them Thursday. They reportedly contacted Murray virtually instantly after he was reduce by the Arizona Cardinals. The Cardinals took on practically $55 million in a lifeless cap hit just to be finished with Murray. And the Vikings could not wait to arrange a gathering with him, and presumably make him their new starter if he’d signal with them.

That says lots about McCarthy’s standing with the Vikings. He did not play effectively final season and has handled many accidents. It’s nonetheless potential McCarthy, who was the tenth decide of the NFL Draft lower than 24 months in the past, may determine issues out and re-emerge as a dependable starter within the NFL, perhaps even for the Vikings. But it appears to be like bleak in the meanwhile.