Fantasy Baseball: ‘Avoid selling high’ on CJ Abrams — skill vs. luck verdicts for key hitters

When a hitter is performing nicely or struggling, the primary query I ask myself is, “Why and how?” Then I ask, “What’s going on under the hood?” It’s straightforward to get misplaced within the weeds with all of the superior metrics obtainable, however the objective is to make this info digestible. Have these hitters been lucky or unlucky? Or have any expertise modified inside their profile? Will these hitters proceed discovering success? Or will they bounce again from their struggles?

Reach out on X (@corbin_young21) in the event you’re enthusiastic about me diving into particular hitters.

commercial

CJ Abrams, Nationals (98% Rostered)

After almost averaging 20 dwelling runs and 30 stolen bases over the previous two seasons, CJ Abrams might surpass that in 2026. Abrams has been lucky, with a career-high BABIP (.336), supporting a career-best batting common. Interestingly, Abrams’ contact charge was a profession low (72.6%), making us ponder whether his 10% stroll charge could be sustained with comparable chase and swing charges in 2026 in comparison with the profession averages. For context, Abrams had a 77.9% contact charge and 35% chase charge all through his profession.

Speaking of luck, Abrams’ dwelling run charge (HR/F) reached a career-high at 16.9% in 2026, primarily supported by his 6.8% barrel charge per plate look. Besides the elevated barrel charge, Abrams has proven constant bat velocity, pull charges and flyball charges, evidenced by a 21-22% pulled air charge over the previous few seasons. Like the remainder of Abrams’ profile, his barrel charge was a profession excessive, two share factors above his profession common (4.8%).

It may be noisy, however Abrams has seen his stolen base alternative charge step by step decline from 2023 (43%) to 2024 (36%) to 2025 (26%) and 2026 (20%). Regardless, it exhibits that Abrams continues to run at a excessive charge, that means 30 stolen bases ought to be an everyday a part of his fantasy profile.

commercial

The projections recommend Abrams might surpass the 25 dwelling run mark whereas almost replicating one other 30 stolen base season. Abrams’ batting common would possibly regress, however it might find yourself nearer to his .260-.270 xBA, making him a near-elite fantasy asset.

Avoid selling excessive, even when we expect the Nationals’ lineup may be overperforming their expectations.

Daylen Lile, Nationals (64% Rostered)

Daylen Lile flashed energy and velocity in his MLB debut in 2025, although his .336 BABIP was fueling the batting common (.299). Meanwhile, Lile’s BABIP has fallen to .292, decreasing his batting common to .264, which continues to be above-average. Lile’s contact charge fell from 83.5% in 2025 to 77% in 2026. Meanwhile, Lile has been chasing extra in 2026 (36.5%) in comparison with 2025 (26.7%), along with his swinging-strike charge leaping to 12.5%, a four-point enhance from 2025 (8.5%).

commercial

As a lefty, Lile makes use of a pull-heavy (43.5%), flyball (42.2%) strategy, aligning with a barely above common pulled air charge (profession common of 18.8%). Lile has mediocre energy, with a 5.6% barrel charge per plate look, that means he’ll want quantity to succeed in 15+ dwelling runs. Fortunately, Lile hits the ball laborious sufficient that he is not a legal responsibility within the dwelling run class to date in 2026, though he by no means reached double-digit dwelling runs within the minors.

From a velocity standpoint, Lile curiously transformed 55% of his stolen base possibilities all through his profession. That’s an terrible conversion charge when Lile safely steals simply over half of his makes an attempt, which could result in managers decreasing his stolen base possibilities. Lile had a 17% stolen base alternative charge in 2025, which dipped barely to 12% in 2026. Fortunately, Lile has been an athletic (ninety fifth percentile Sprint Speed) and defensive (79th percentile Outs Above Average) specimen, usually resulting in potential steals.

Play 2026 Soccer Pick ‘Em with FOX One and make your picks for the world’s biggest soccer tournament

commercial

There’s the potential for 15 dwelling runs and 15 stolen bases as his flooring throughout a full season, which is efficacious in deeper codecs.

JJ Bleday, Reds (34% Rostered)

After being the fourth total decide within the 2019 draft, JJ Bleday has been a post-hype sleeper for a number of seasons. Bleday had considerations about strikeouts and get in touch with charges previously. He has proven comparable contact, chase and swing charges in 2026, inside 1-2 share factors of his profession averages. The most vital skill change includes Bleday’s 74.7 mph bat velocity, which is over 2.5 factors above his profession common (72 mph). That stated, Bleday has been swinging quicker at a excessive share (50.4%), indicating he posted a bat velocity of 75 mph or extra half the time.

Bleday’s bat velocity stays an enter into the facility metrics. We can speculate on Bleday’s elevated energy inputs, positively impacting his career-best 10.3% barrel charge per plate look. That primarily comes from Bleday’s pull-heavy (48.4%) and flyball (50%) strategy, as he makes an attempt to lean into the pull-heavy profile. Both metrics have been 3-5 share factors greater than his profession common. It was a bit extra drastic earlier within the season, with pull and flyball charges at 55% or greater. There could be diminishing returns when pulling balls into the air too typically.

When Bleday pulled the ball into the air, he boasted a 97.9 mph common exit velocity, 75.1 mph bat velocity, 89.5% ideally suited assault angle and a .912 wOBA (.687 xwOBA) in 2026. This is what it appears like when a hitter with above-average energy faucets extra into their pull aspect by swinging quicker and hitting the ball more durable.

commercial

Bleday has been messing along with his batting stance too, utilizing a considerably extra open one at 28 levels open in comparison with 11 levels open in his profession. There’s additionally an intentional strategy to hit the ball in entrance of the plate (5.3 inches) in 2026 and 2025 (5.1 inches), supporting the pull charges.

The extra open stance and intercept level additional in entrance of the plate over the previous two seasons might have helped him carry out higher towards breaking pitches. That’s very true when he turns on a breaking ball coming towards him from a right-handed pitcher. It’s regular to be skeptical of Bleday’s batted ball outcomes, particularly by way of non-fastballs. Bleday has been obliterating the breaking balls, evidenced by a .708 wOBA (.506 xwOBA) in 2026, up from a .340 wOBA (.291 xwOBA) in 2025.

Bleday’s elevated bat velocity and energy inputs have positively impacted him in 2026, main us shopping for into the completely different strategy and expertise to assist the early season manufacturing. He ought to replicate one thing just like 2024 with greater than 20 dwelling runs, making him an underrated purchase or maintain based mostly on the talents in deeper codecs.

commercial

Miguel Vargas, White Sox (79% Rostered)

We’re lastly seeing the upside for Miguel Vargas in 2026. Vargas has been an asset in OBP and factors leagues, boasting almost equivalent strikeout (16.9%) and stroll charges (15%). His improved on-base expertise and decrease strikeout charges have been supported by a career-best 85.4% contact charge and career-low 17.3% chase charge. For context, Vargas’ contact and chase charges in 2026 are 4-5 share factors higher than the profession norm.

Vargas initiatives to hit a profession excessive in dwelling runs, given his above-average bat velocity (73.7 mph), growing by over two mph in 2026 from his profession common. Furthermore, Vargas has a 41.1% fast-swing share, greater than double his profession norm (16.4%), indicating he constantly swings more durable. Swinging quicker would not at all times lead towards optimum outcomes, however Vargas’ sturdy plate self-discipline along with his above-average bat velocity interprets to a career-best 10.2% barrel charge per plate look.

commercial

Like Vargas’ dwelling run projection, he’ll set a profession excessive in stolen bases. That’s primarily as a result of Vargas has been working barely extra typically, with a 13% stolen base alternative charge in 2026, up from 7% in his profession. Vargas used to have upside for 20 dwelling runs and 10 stolen bases, however we’re seeing hints at one other degree with 25+ dwelling runs and 15 stolen bases being possible in 2026.

I might purchase Vargas the place obtainable, particularly in OBP and factors codecs. That stated, monitor Vargas’ well being after being hit by a pitch on his hand on Tuesday.

Randy Arozarena, Mariners (97% Rostered)

Randy Arozarena has been one of many Mariners’ finest hitters in 2026. After we have seen Arozarena’s batting common decline, his .385 BABIP fuels his batting common spike this season, so there’s some luck in his favor. Interestingly, Arozarena has been chasing extra (31.9%) whereas sustaining his contact charge (73.6%) in 2026. For context, Arozarena’s chase charge can be a profession worst, 5 factors above his profession common. It’s most likely unreliable, however Arozarena has been making extra contact exterior the zone (69.4%), which could not be the very best course of since that is almost 10 factors greater than his profession common.

Arozarena has been hitting loads of groundballs, 53.3% of the time in 2026, up from 42.5% in 2025. Although his groundball charge negatively impacts his energy, it may well assist his BABIP as a hitter with above-average velocity like Arozarena. That stated, Arozarena’s barrel charge per plate look has dropped to three.8% in 2026 from 6.9% (2025). Furthermore, Arozarena’s Exit Velocity 50 or EV50 was above-average in 2025, given his 102.5 mph EV50 (No. 55), tying him with Christian Walker and Shea Langeliers final season. Like Arozarena’s barrel charge, his EV50 has fallen to 100.3 mph (No. 125) in 2026.

commercial

That tells us Arozarena nonetheless hits the ball laborious, however possibly not within the high-end vary.

Arozarena is on tempo for 30+ stolen bases once more whereas persevering with to run at a excessive charge, with a 28% stolen base alternative charge, just like 2025 (24%). Running typically and changing 85% of your possibilities will assist keep and increase Arozarena’s fantasy worth. Arozarena may very well be extra like 2022, with 20 dwelling runs and 32 stolen bases in 2026, particularly if he struggles to raise the ball extra constantly this yr.

It appears like extra of the identical with Arozarena, with the potential for the next batting common, though it is most likely fluky in that division.